Posts

An Eighth Man: Reflections on Migrant Workers in Japan by William Andrews

Image
    Describing his pamphlet, An Eighth Man: Reflections on Migrant Workers in Japan , William Andrews explains that: “Much as the experience of migration is not uniform, so too are these texts disparate and uneven.” There is, however, an organizing principle. “This text,” Andrews writes, “is neither anti- nor pro-immigrant; it is an anti-capitalist text.” The disparate texts focus not on individual migrants nor on specific xenophobes, though of course individual migrants and specific xenophobes form part of the discussion. Rather, Andrews looks at the forces that lead migrants to leave their homes, and how countries like Japan use them to keep late stage capitalist enterprise humming: “the logic of capital eager to escape a death spiral.”       Japan needs migrant workers, but that doesn’t mean such workers are welcome. The “xenophobic falsehoods” one can find all too easily on the Internet are evidence of that.   Andrews describ...

Climbers by M. John Harrison

Image
  M. John Harrison has just won the Booker Prize for his most recent novel, The End of Everything . Thus I'm several years late and a dollar short in publishing this review of his 1989 novel Climbers . Harrison is best known for his science fiction, so the first thing to note about Climbers  is that it is not science fiction. (It seems pretty clear, from the reviews I've read, that The End of Everything isn't either.)   It is a climbing novel, and won the Boardman-Tasker prize for mountain literature, but for many reasons it would be a mistake to slot it into any of the categories that might suggest. In place of pristine landscapes, or outdoorsy nature writing we get disused quarries and the industrial detritus of Northern England; in place of wholesome young mountain athletes we get working class and sub-working class climbers surviving in England during the dark days of late Thatcherism, and in place of the sort of upward and onward success for which ascending a r...

The Echo of Crows by Phil Rickman

Image
  As unlikely it sounds, even as anti-clerical and irreligious as I am, I have enjoyed Phil Rickman's series of novels about a Church of England exorcist (the Church still has them, but now calls them "Deliverance Ministers"), and the mysteries she encounters which, if I recall correctly, usually seem to have solutions that are in large part material, but don't rule out the supernatural. One of the ongoing threads in the novel is the tension between the exorcist, Merrily Watkins, and the increasingly secularizing Church which no longer has much time for woo-woo explanations of evil. That, for the space of the novels, my sympathies were with Merrily is surely the result of Rickman's skill in creating characters who convince us. And as is the case with all successful series, it is the recurring characters that keep us coming back. We look forward to updates about the lives of her crusty old mentor, about Merrily's lover, Lol, a folkie singer-songwriter who is al...

Piedra de Sol / Sunstone by Octavio Paz. Translated by Eliot Weinberger

Image
 I've read this poem three times in the last four days. Reading, rereading, and rereading again seems the appropriate way to experience this book, which draws for its structure on the Aztec sun calendar and the cyclical notion of time it embodies. I guess it qualifies as a long poem, though as it's only about 25 pages long, in each of the languages in which it is presented, one has to ask: Compared to what? I came across one scholar who likens it to "The Waste Land," and I can't help but suspect that it is that the poems are of similar length (Paz's offering is 150 lines longer) and the fact that their concerns are wide ranging, that drive that observation (Paz's poem is the more wide ranging).  The styles in which the poems are written, for example, have little in common. Paz writes in regular hendecasyllabic  eight-line stanzas; Eliot does not. The form Paz has chosen, and which Weinberger, wisely, does not slavishly follow in the English translation, gi...

Steppenwolf by Herman Hesse

Image
   The first section of Herman Hesse's Steppenwolf  is is all about the Steppenwolf, aka Harry Haller, and offers, in these opening pages, a simple notion of identity: Our identity is composed of, or at least Haller believes that his identity is composed of, two battling parts: the Dionysian and the Apollonian. I'm using Nietzsche's terms, because much of this book seems to be a rehash of some of that philosopher's thought. Later this theory of a bifurcated identity is altered to say that we each have not two sides, but many. This is the book's great reveal, but the combination of a self-obsessed character and facile philosophy and psychology in the opening pages almost made me put it down before I got there. It gets better when we get a glimpse outside Harry's head: A new character, Hermine, appears. She seems to understand Harry for what he is, and calls him out on at least some of his nonsense while also teaching him the popular dances of the day. This is nee...

The Sea View Has Me Again: Uwe Johnson in Sheerness by Patrick Wright

Image
   Patrick Wright has chosen to focus his massive account of the last ten years of Uwe Johnson's life, spent in Sheerness , on the place. The detail we absorb from Wright about this neglected and depressed locale—I seem to remember it being referred to as "the back end of the Thames"—is staggering. It seems trite to say that the places we spend our days make us who we are, but how many biographers take that seriously? Most seem content to tell us what their subjects do while more or less ignoring where they were. Wright, adopting the opposite approach, focuses most of his 750 or so pages on the bleak, depressed place Johnson made his home. In those pages we do get the facts of Johnson's life, but much more we get the facts of Sheerness, Sheppy, and the bleak place that was England in the 1970s.  The book's great strength is its discursiveness. From Sheppy and Johnson, Wright journeys widely., and as much as we enjoy reading about our subject, especially in the sub...

The Crossing by Michael Connelly

Image
 The race continues. Can I keep going long enough to finish Michael Connelly's ongoing series of Harry Bosch novels or will I die before Bosch? The good news is, after The Crossing , the 18th in the series, I still enjoy the books enough that I want to give it my best shot (though it wouldn't make me sad if Bosch's story continues even after mine has ended).  Bosch is now officially retired again—he's already retired once, but then come back under a special program allowing retired detectives to return to duty. He is, however, suing the LAPD for forcing him out: He still doesn't like retirement. Mickey Haller, a defense attorney who, it was revealed several novels back, is actually Bosch's brother, something of which neither of them had been aware, contacts him and asks him to work for him as an investigator.  Haller has his own Connelly series, so this book is a crossover. I have a vague memory of reading one Haller book, and not being eager to go back for more...

Stoner by John Williams

Image
 It is tempting to read  Stoner,  the story of a man in an unhappy marriage, thwarted in his career, and not quite able to be the teacher or scholar he wants to be, as relentlessly bleak. And yet, in the course of the protagonist William Stoner's life, he manages to experience the aesthetic bliss that one can find in the best art, to experience love (also passionate sex), albeit outside his marriage, and also to experience paternal love in the early years of his relationship with his daughter. The view of life Williams presents us with is in no way idealized; it is a realistic account of the good accompanied by the bad, a combination with which most us will be familiar. Stoner is, for most of the book, a university professor. There is nothing in the account of his life and career that is surprising or exciting. It is, in short, mundane. Reading Williams's account of it, though, we find ourselves affected by something that lies just beneath the surface. As in, for example,...

Die Trying by Lee Child

Image
 Having now read the first two Reacher books in quick succession I am coming to the conclusion that the series has a great strength which is also a weakness: Jack Reacher.  This entirely rootless and ruthlessly competent man is an incarnation of a fantasy that appeals to many of us. The sections of this novel that feature him are a treat. The problem is, there are sections where the POV character shifts, and they are uniformly less interesting than the Reacher sections. One scurries through them to get back to the main attraction. The main attraction will certainly draw me back, but maybe not right away. In Die Trying Reacher is dealing with a right wing group based on the sort of wackos that used to infest the less populated parts of Michigan and the American West. Reading the novel, published in 1998, takes one back to a simpler time when we could view these militia types as fringe wierdos and usually not much more. Alas, that was long before they and their sympathizers inf...

The Waves by Virginia Woolf

Image
      After telling her that he thought The Waves was a masterpiece, Virginia Woolf's husband and first reader, Leonard, added that he "thinks the first 100 pages extremely difficult, & is doubtful how far any common reader will follow." I'm not sure if I qualify as a "common reader," but I maybe I am, because Leonard was spot on: It took me about 100 pages to learn how to read The Waves . The rest was pure pleasure. As I move through Woolf's novels, I am delighted to find that she never seems to have let herself get into a rut. In each novel she tries something new. In The Waves it is the presentation of six characters (and a seventh whose voice we never hear) through internal monologues—the stories they tell about themselves at different stages of their lives. Woolf shows us, by the end that, though they are individuals, they also form a sort of grid: they are all part of each other. Waves, we remember, are each separate from the other, but are b...

We Keep the Dead Close: A Murder at Harvard and a Half Century of Silence by Becky Cooper

Image
  Becky Cooper has worked at The New Yorker  and has written a good many articles for them (mostly about food and restaurants) including the four-parter that she would expand (and expand and expand) into this book. One of the great things about The New Yorker is their willingness to go long, whether that means devoting a significant chunk of one issue to an in depth exploration, or spreading that exploration over a few issues. Their commitment to long-form journalism is what keeps many of us reading it. There's such a thing, though, as giving a story that needs space too much space, and that is the problem with Becky Cooper's We Keep the Dead Close . In sharing with us seemingly every detail of her amateur quest to figure out who murdered a Harvard graduate student named Jane Britton, and throwing in the plight of women in academia over the last half-century, #MeToo, our propensity to tell stories and make myths about inexplicable events, and even her own relationship with a ...

The Rings of Saturn by W.G. Sebald, translated by Michael Hulse

Image
  With the possible exception of László Krasznahorkai , there is no writer of recent times who is as ambitious, as original, as brilliant as W.G Sebald. I knew this when I read the first of his books to be translated into English, The Emigrants , and moving through the rest of his oeuvre only convinces me further that this is the case. The Rings of Saturn  is a travel book: Sebald/not Sebald takes a long walk through Sussex. Unlike lesser examples of the genre, though, there are no "hilarious" encounters with locals or with other travelers. Instead we get reflections on history, on literature, and on landscape, rendered in such a way that they are at once somber, dreamlike, allusive, horrifying (and occasionally laugh-out-loud funny). The walker, in the course of his English stroll, calls up Thomas Browne ("Hydriotaphia, urn burial; with an account of some urns found at Brampton in Norfolk") and Edward FitzGerald (translator of Omar Khayyam), and visits his friend M...

Killing Floor by Lee Child

Image
 This is the first published of Lee Child's Jack Reacher series. I read it a long time ago, but had mostly forgotten it. What I hadn't forgotten is the character, Jack Reacher. In giving us a man who moves through the world free of all the burdens that our societies and cultures place upon us, and also unbothered by having to forego the wonderful things that our societies and cultures make available to us, Lee Child gives us an attractive fantasy. Imagine being entirely unburdened and free. But of course things can't be that simple. Reacher inevitably gets involved in something. In this case his brother, with whom, like everyone else who has passed through his life, he has been out of touch, is murdered, and his murder turns out to be one small piece of a large pile of crime and corruption. Reacher ends up having to put things right.   With admirable competence and cool—this, too, is part of the fantasy—Reacher does put things right. Having done so, he leaves town, realiz...

East of Eden by John Steinbeck

Image
     Like most Americans of my generation, I read a couple of novels by John Steinbeck in the course of my education. In my case—maybe in everybody's case—one of them was Of Mice and Men , but I also read  The Pearl . I remember enjoying them, but somehow, as I matured as a reader, I never wanted to continue through Steinbeck's oeuvre. I'm glad that some friends invited me to join in a group read of East of Eden , because, though I probably wouldn't have picked it up on my own, I enjoyed it tremendously.      I tend to dislike books overburdened with "philosophy" and "messages." East of Eden is rich in both, but somehow they don't capsize the ship. Using the story of Cain and Abel as his source, Steinbeck is able to reflect on family, on what he would have called "blood" but  we now prefer to think of as DNA, and most effectively on good and evil.  To say that everyone has some bad, some evil, some of the devil in them is banal. Wh...

Doctor Syn on the High Seas by Russell Thorndyke

Image
 This is a boy's-own-adventure. It was published in 1936, and offers everything that boy's-own-adventures from that period offer. Boys, and children in general, were not assumed to be stupid at that time. The vocabulary is much richer than one would find in books intended for young people in our time.  The hero, Doctor Syn, is not any sort of role model. He's filled with hatred for the man for whom his wife, of her own free will, left him. The whole novel is about Syn, driven by his hatred, tracking that man. He has lots of adventures in the course of pursuing his vendetta, and they are satisfyingly adventurous.  The things that boys'-own-adventures from the good old days offer include also things that are much less attractive. It is assumed, for example, that readers will chuckle along with, or even worse, learn from, the denigration of people of African descent. A black man captains a pirate ship. He and his crew kill, pillage, and rape—you know, pirate stuff—but the ...

The Counterfeiters by André Gide. Translated by Dorothy Bussy.

Image
 André Gide kept a journal while writing The Counterfeiters . In it, he quotes from a newspaper clipping about the trial of a gang of counterfeiters: When the judge asked Fréchaut if he had been a member of the Luxembourg "gang":      "Let's call it 'the coterie,' your honor," he replied warmly. "It was a gathering where we dealt in counterfeit money, I don't deny that; but we were principally concerned with questions of politics and literature." It is clear that Gide had Fréchaut's description in mind when he composed his novel. It is, indeed, about counterfeiting ("I don't deny that") but it is about many other things as well.  The novel is usually classed as "modernist." The primary reasons for that would seem to be the many plots and stories, some of which remain unresolved, that crisscross through its pages (including a novel within the The Counterfeiters called, of course, "The Counterfeiters," a...

Esprit de Corps by Lawrence Durrell

Image
This is a slight collection in every way. The Faber and Faber edition that I read clocks in at 89 pages. Each of the nine stories is short, and the tone is always light. I picked it up because I had enjoyed the parts of the Alexandria Quartet , especially in Mountolive , that deal with diplomacy, which is the subject of these tales, too: the "Corps" in question is the diplomatic corps. The stories didn't exactly scratch the itch for more Mountolivian diplomacy, because the tone of these slight sketches is entirely different from anything in the novels. One imagines that at least some of these tales were written at the same time that Durrell was working on the Quartet , and it's hard not to guess that they were what Durrell, having poured himself a drink, turned to after a full day of Justine, Nessim, Balthazar, and all the rest. Much of the humor is built around national stereotypes and as such, can seem dated. A lot of it, though, still works. Take, for example, this...

Lazarus Man by Richard Price

Image
 As Christopher Hitchens famously argued, "religion poisons everything." This may or may not be true (I'm going with "true"), but in the case of Richard Price's Lazarus Man , it's hard not to believe that religion or something like it has made him a worse writer than he was when he was composing novels like Clockers and writing screenplays for The Wire .   Clockers  was entirely successful because of its gritty realism, a realism that left no place for sentimentality, let alone quasi-religious self-help messages.  The Wire , inspired in part by Clockers , and among the best narrative art of our time, was likewise clear-eyed and hard-hitting. The "Lazarus" of the title, Anthony, whose life is a mess, is apparently buried for three days in a Harlem building collapse. The unlikelihood of his resurrection makes him a minor celebrity, and, on the basis of his experience, he becomes a popular speaker. He tells an audience, at one point,  I never bee...

The Evening of the Holiday by Shirley Hazzard

Image
 With Transit of Venus , The Bay of Noon , and The Great Fire , Shirley Hazzard has written some of the great novels of our time. Everyone has to start somewhere, though. The Evening of the Holiday , Hazzard's first novel, is where she started. It is, as is partly true of all her books, a love story. In this case a half-Italian half-English woman becomes involved with an Italian in Italy. As always, Hazzard writes about the affair meticulously. No sentence is less than perfect, but the book, as short as it is, was a bit of a slog. It didn't, for me, come to life until the last page or two. It is there that we see the writer Hazzard was to become. The affair, as both parties knew it would have to, has come to an end. The protagonist is on a train, the first leg of her trip back to England. There are soldiers on the train, among them a bugler who tries to play whenever the train stops:  The wistful music filled the train and floated out on the cold dark station of every town we ...

Orlando by Virginia Woolf

Image
 It was brave of Virginia Woolf, in the wake of Mrs Dalloway and To the Lighthouse , to try something completely different in her next novel, Orlando . Nothing like what had come before, it is a historical fantasia, and it is hard to imagine that Woolf didn't have fun writing it. Alas, however, it's not as much fun for the reader as it must have been for the author. There is humor and sparkling prose. It's Virginia Woolf we're talking about, after all. But the humor isn't always as humorous as it should be, and the prose, at times, doesn't sparkle brightly enough to hold one's interest. That's my take, but what do I know? It was extremely popular in its day, so much so that it made Virginia, Leonard, and the struggling Hogarth Press financially solvent for the first time. The novel is groundbreaking in its treatment of gender, but in terms of style, it seems less interesting than the narrative experiments Woolf had pulled off successfully in her previou...